Studying the interactions between a protease and its protein substrates at a molecular level is crucial for identifying the factors facilitating selection of particular proteolytic substrates and not others. These selection criteria include both the sequence and the local context of the substrate cleavage site where the active site of the protease initially binds and then performs proteolytic cleavage. Caspase-9, an initiator of the intrinsic apoptotic pathway, mediates activation of executioner procaspase-3 by cleavage of the intersubunit linker (ISL) at site 172IETD↓S. Although procaspase-6, another executioner, possesses two ISL cleavage sites (site 1, 176DVVD↓N; site 2, 190TEVD↓A), neither is directly cut by caspase-9. Thus, caspase-9 directly activates procaspase-3 but not procaspase-6. To elucidate this selectivity of caspase-9, we engineered constructs of procaspase-3 (e.g., swapping the ISL site, 172IETD↓S, with DVVDN and TEVDA) and procaspase-6 (e.g., swapping site 1, 176DVVD↓N, and site 2, 190TEVD↓A, with IETDS). Using the substrate digestion data of these constructs, we show here that the P4-P1' sequence of procaspase-6 ISL site 1 (DVVDN) can be accessed but not cleaved by caspase-9. We also found that caspase-9 can recognize the P4-P1' sequence of procaspase-6 ISL site 2 (TEVDA); however, the local context of this cleavage site is the critical factor that prevents proteolytic cleavage. Overall, our data have demonstrated that both the sequence and the local context of the ISL cleavage sites play a vital role in preventing the activation of procaspase-6 directly by caspase-9.