ABSTRACT Expression of the PrfA-controlled virulence gene hly (encoding the pore-forming cytolysin listeriolysin) is under negative regulation by readily metabolized carbon sources in Listeria monocytogenes . However, the hyperhemolytic strain NCTC 7973 exhibits deregulated hly expression in the presence of repressing sugars, raising the possibility that a defect in carbon source regulation is responsible for its anomalous behavior. We show here that the activity of a second glucose-repressed enzyme, α-glucosidase, is 10-fold higher in NCTC 7973 than in 10403S. Using hly-gus fusions, we show that the prfA allele from NCTC 7973 causes deregulated hly-gus expression in the presence of sugars in either the wild-type or the NCTC 7973 background, while the 10403S prfA allele restores carbon source regulation. However, the prfA genotype does not affect the regulation of α-glucosidase activity by repressing sugars. Of the two mutational differences in PrfA, only a Gly145Ser change is important for regulation of hly-gus . Therefore, NCTC 7973 and 10403S have genetic differences in at least two loci: one in prfA that affects carbon source regulation of virulence genes and another in an unidentified gene(s) that up-regulates α-glucosidase activity. We also show that the decrease in pH associated with utilization of sugars negatively regulates hly-gus expression, although sugars can affect hly-gus expression by another mechanism that is independent of pH.