<i>Aims:</i> Hyperandrogenism, although mostly due to polygenic interactions, is monogenic for some enzymatic adrenal deficiencies. This study evaluates mono- and biallelic 21-hydroxylase deficiency (21OHD)-related hyperandrogenism in pediatric patients. Sensitizing and protective polymorphisms were investigated in carriers and cryptic forms of 21OHD. <i>Methods:</i> The study involved a monogenic analysis of CYP21A2 in patients (375 nonclassical 21OHD [NC21OHD] children; 306 hyperandrogenic 21OHD carriers, n = 306) and a polygenic association study (CAPN10-UCSNP44, PON1-108, TNFR2-M196R, IGF2-ApaI and IRS1-G972R polymorphisms) of 170 hyperandrogenic carriers plus 277 family members (control groups). The metabolic marker 17OH progesterone defined the degree of deficiency; clinical expressivity was determined by pediatric endocrinologists. <i>Results:</i> The group of 21OHD carriers manifesting hyperandrogenism was enriched in the CAPN-UCSNP44 rare variant in homozygosity (4.9 vs. 0.4%, NCBI data for the general population; p = 0.004). In our patients and controls, contrasting distributions were observed for this and another polymorphism, TNFR2-196R. In a recessive model, their rare variants were more frequently detected among the forms with high (p = 0.048) and low (p = 0.034) expressivity respectively. <i>Conclusions:</i> 21OHD-related pediatric hyperandrogenism follows monogenic and polygenic models. The opposite behaviors in terms of clinical expressivity detected for CAPN-UCSNP44 and TNFR2-M196R rare variants suggest these variants to be sensitizing and protective factors respectively in adrenal hyperandrogenism.