Mature 31- and 34-kDa inhibin A and B negatively regulate the release of FSH from the anterior pituitary; however, a direct comparison of these hormones in vivo has not been undertaken. The bioactivities of highly purified preparations of recombinant human 31-kDa inhibin A and B were determined in rat pituitary cells in vitro, and in ovariectomized adult rats in vivo based on suppression of plasma FSH. The 31-kDa inhibin B was 4.2-fold more bioactive than inhibin A in vitro and 1.45 (1.01-2.79)-fold more bioactive in vivo than 31-kDa inhibin A. However, the corresponding relative binding affinities of 31-kDa inhibin B for betaglycan, betaglycan+activin type II receptor (ActRII)-A, and betaglycan+ActRIIB were lower (IC(50) 2200, 400, and 750 pm, respectively) compared with 31-kDa inhibin A (IC(50) 190, 80, and 290 pm, respectively). A 2.7- and 2.5-fold reduction in in vitro bioactivity was observed between the 31- and 34-kDa inhibin A and 31- and 34-kDa inhibin B, respectively, and these decreases in bioactivities were matched by a parallel reduction in binding to betaglycan and betaglycan+ActRIIA/B. It is concluded that the increased in vitro and in vivo bioactivities of 31-kDa inhibin B cannot be explained by a higher affinity to betaglycan or activin type II receptors; thus, additional factors mediate inhibin B's action. In addition, similar reductions in in vitro bioactivity and betaglycan+ActRIIA/B binding between 31- and 34-kDa inhibins A and B are attributed to hindrance by the additional carbohydrate group at Asn(302) in the formation of a functional inhibin+betaglycan+ActRIIA/B complex.